Category Archives: news

Is the Vatican the next genocide denier?

Last month President Yushchenko invited Pope Benedict to Ukraine to set up a working group to research and study historical documents in the Vatican Secret Archives related to Ukraine, including the Holodomor.

Unfortunately what they got was Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, a Secretary of State who loves the lime light – he appeared on many TV shows and articles denouncing the Da Vinci code and on his first day on the job announced “the Pope’s option in favour of inter-religious and inter-cultural dialogue is equally unequivocal”.  His attitude towards the Holodomor isn’t any better:

“The Ukrainian people and authorities perceive the tragedy of the Holodomor very painfully primarily because, as we know, the tremendous failure of crops that affected Ukraine in those years provoked the death of seven million people,” Bertone said.

Crop failure, are you serious?  It’s such an outdated defense not even the deniers are using it anymore!  Even the slightest amount of research will draw you the conclusion that the Holodomor was the result of a state-sponsored famine through confiscation (Fact #2), not a natural catastrophe.

The new direction the Vatican is taking is a complete turn around from the days of Pope John Paul II who was a staunch opponent of Communism.  He addressed to Ukraine on the 70th anniversary of the Holodomor:

These are the sentiments that the 70th anniversary of the consequences of the Holodomor tragedy awakens in my heart: millions of people suffered an atrocious death due to the nefarious success of an ideology that caused suffering and bereavement in many parts of the world throughout the 20th century. It is for this reason, Venerable Brothers, that I want to be present in spirit at the celebrations to commemorate the countless victims of the great famine instigated in Ukraine by the Communist regime. It was an inhuman scheme put into effect in cold blood by those in power at the time.

As is proving more and more evident, larger groups of concentrated power aren’t beneficial to the individual no matter what group you belong to.

I’m still looking up how to contact Cardinal Bertone.

Manitoba recognizes the Holodomor as genocide

Last Thursday was the final sitting of the Manitoba legislature before it breaks for the summer, and a historic bill passed that received little media fan-fare:

The lone opposition bill passed was one establishing the fourth Saturday in November as Ukrainian Famine and Genocide Holodomor Memorial Day.

Bill 217 received royal assent on June 12, 2008 and was introduced by Selkirk-Interlake MP James Bezan who also got a similar bill passed in the Senate along with Etobicoke-Centre MP Borys Wrzesnewskyj to recognize the genocide nationwide.

First Saskatchewan, now Manitoba and Ontario is next with Bill-C61 that has been ordered referred to the Standing Committee on Regulations and Private Bills.

Holodomor left off of TDSB’s genocide curriculum


From the Toronto Sun:

Leaders of an “insulted” Ukrainian community last night blasted the Toronto District School Board for approving a genocide class that doesn’t include the 1932-33 Holodomor in its list of three atrocities to be studied in-depth.

The TDSB last night unanimously approved the course design for the Grade 11 genocide class, which will focus mainly on three mass murders — the 1915 Armenian genocide, the Holocaust, and the 1994 Rwandan genocide.

But a board superintendent, Nadine Segal, said other genocides, including the current Darfur crisis as well as the Soviet-engineered Ukrainian Holodomor famine, will be touched upon in a broader, survey context. Students will have the opportunity to choose other genocides for independent study, Segal said.


From the Globe and Mail:

A group of Ukrainian-Canadians sat in the board meeting’s audience in support of an effort to have the Holodomor, the 1932-33 Ukrainian genocide, included as a core case study.

The board passed some minor amendments aimed at bolstering the profile of the Holodomor in the curriculum, including a mandatory statement that crimes against humanity not used as one of the three core case studies were not of lesser importance than those that were, and that other atrocities could be included as case studies.

While most of the media focused on the Armenian-Turkish battle over the course, it was refreshing to see some bring up the issue and keep the topic fresh in the media. The course unfortunately will not be reviewed for another three years.

Meanwhile in 2009 Alberta will start teaching the Holodomor and the internment of Ukrainians during WWI in its schools, the League of Ukrainian Canadians have had their Holodomor education plan posted for quite some time, and there are plenty more resources in the US.

Show your support – Demand TDSB approve Holodomor in genocide curriculum today!

Contact your Trustee by phone, email or fax and demand that the Holodomor be included in the genocide studies. A list of contacts can be found at:
http://www.tdsb.on.ca/boardroom/trustees/index.asp

Send an email to the Chair and members of the School Board requesting the same:
John Campbell, Chair and Members of the TDSB
john.campbell@tdsb.on.ca
Gerry Connelly, Director of Education
Gerry.Connelly@tdsb.on.ca

Come out to the Special Board meeting, June 12, 6:00pm at the TDSB Board Room,
5050 Yonge St., Toronto.

When calling trustees you can start out with:
Have they ever heard of the Holodomor — the Famine-Genocide in Ukraine?

More than likely they will say they haven’t thus allowing us to inform them, etc.

Then challenge their vote if you detect that they are going to vote against inclusion of the Holodomor – as they should be voting on an informed basis and for sound pedagogical reasons. Keep track of those who say they haven’t heard of it or those who seem to know little about it and send them supplemental information and request an in person meeting to brief them
The TDSB committee clearly stated that they did not exclude the Holodmor,  that there is plenty of opportunity to research it and study it. But we all know that if a topic is not a mandatory part of a curriculum (which it is not, only 3 are), the teachers will not teach it and the kids won’t find ‘it’ to research it.

This is a very important point, and the TDSB have been able to answer
questions using this very point, which is a lameduck argument.
Purpose in writing/calling:
Include the Holodomor in the core curriculum – genocide studies
Why:

  • Canadian government recognized Holodomor as genocide and identified the 4th Saturday in November as Holodomor Memorial Day.
  • Several provinces recognized Holodomor as genocide – Bill is currently before Ontario Legislation.
  • Scholars and Historians have documented the famine as a genocide. New documents are emerging almost daily.
  • Over 3,000,000 of the victims were children.
  • 15 countries, with more to follow, have recognized the Holodomor as a genocide.
  • Director’s Report acknowledges that more people died in the Ukrainian famine than in the 3 genocides currently approved.
  • The Holodomor was the only genocide to be executed in peace time.
  • Largely ignored, no media coverage due to Stalin being an ally of the West.
  • Holodomor meets the Geneva Convention’s definition of Genocide.
  • Communist propaganda, supported by NY times journalist Walter Duranty, was purposely misleading. FDR referred to Stalin as “Uncle Joe”
  • Stalin’s crimes exceed those of Hitler by a factor of 3-4 times.
  • Communists and Leftists continue to cover up Stalin’s crimes.
  • Many school boards in Canada, US and other countries are teaching about the Holodomor as an act of genocide.
  • Russia continues to deny it, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
  • The Holodomor is not general public knowledge.
  • The Holodomor can be easily incorporated into the existing core program, as teachers have indicated. Resource materials are available and a summer writing team can easily prepare a teaching unit.
  • Overall, the intent of the Holodomor was to wipe out the Ukrainian people.
  • No reason was given or suggested by the TDSB why the Holodomor cannot be included. The Review Committee is not well represented and has no specialist on Ukrainian or East European history.
  • There was no consultation with the Ukrainian community, given that there are over 100,000 Canadians of Ukrainian origin in the GTA.
  • With the recent visit of President Yushchenko and the media coverage of the Holodomor, students are asking questions and would like to do further research.
  • The Ukrainian documentation centre has a wealth of books and other materials on the Holodomor.
  • The Holodomor is an example of a Communist-perpetrated genocide.
  • Stalin’s Holodomor gave the greenlight for Hitler’s Holocaust, since the Holodomor was successfully concealed and hidden to the West.
  • At the June 2nd meeting, Board officials mislead the public by stating there are resources available on the Holodomor within the TDSB course.

These are only guidelines. I hope you find these useful. Feel free to expand or use other arguments.

From the latest ePoshta.

UPDATE:   Looks like the Toronto Sun has taken notice of tonight’s vote, also here is a press release for tonight.

TDSB turns a blind eye to the Holodomor

By Alex Chumak, Former Toronto School Trustee

What does one have to do to persuade the Toronto District School Board to include the Holodomor/Genocide as part of its curriculum? At the present time, the Toronto Board will be teaching the following genocides -the Holocaust, Armenian and Rwandan – in its Genocide Program. These were the recommendations of a Review Committee that ostensibly researched many genocides and concluded to teach only these three.

To its credit, the Toronto Board has established an appeal process where the wider community could express its views on the genocide program and request that, in this case, the Ukrainian genocide should be included in the curriculum. Presumably, the information provided at the appeal would be evaluated on its merit, considered carefully and, based on the information given, would render a decision that is both fair and educationally sound. Not so with the Toronto Board’s Program and School Services Committee which was hearing the appeal.

On June 2, 2008 , under the auspices of the Ukrainian Canadian Committee – Toronto Branch, the Holodomor committee presented educational reasons why the Holodomor should be included in the Board’s curriculum. The deputants argued passionately, with adequate documentation and sound educational arguments, that the Holodomor should be included in the curriculum. But this did not happen.

Continue reading TDSB turns a blind eye to the Holodomor